Writing Seminar: Summary
'07 February 2013
Summary of " The parable of Violence in the Older West”
In the article, " The Myth of Violence in the Old West, ” Roger D. McGrath attempts to rebut the common myth in the old west being plagued by high criminal offense rate. Even though McGrath agreed that the outdated west was violent, this individual maintained how a violence in those days was dissimilar from the modern. To help illustrate his stage, he in comparison today's offense rate intended for burglary, thievery, and killing in main cities, with this of Bodie. While belonging to the most well known towns with the old western world, Bodies offense rate did not seem to bother the old, youthful, weak, or perhaps women as they have done therefore in significant cities today. Over a five year period, McGrath explained, a ratio of 84 Robberies per 100, 1000 inhabitants each year occurred through the flourishing years of 1878-1882, as the United States overall was 243. He described that the offense rate of burglary and robbery was deterred by the fact that most citizens, in Bodie, where always provided and without hesitation of taking pictures the home-owners robber. One area of crime Bodie significantly surpassed that of the 1980's major urban centers was murder. While the tough rate of Bodie was 116, in comparison to the national common in 80 of 12. 2, the people involved had been the small, adventurous, sole males who adhere to a code of conduct that quit frequently required these to fight, even if, of perhaps especially if, it could possibly mean fatality (Par 14). Even with a great astronomically large murder level, Bodie only convicted one man of murder. McGrath openly lays out robust arguments to contradict the normal myth in the old west being this lawless, offense rampant come apart of our history a number of us have come to believe.
McGrath, Robert. " The parable of Violence in the Older West, ” Gunfighters, Highwaymen, and Vigilantes: Violence for the Frontier. Regents of the U of California, 1984.
Offered: McGrath, Robert. " The Myth of Violence in the Outdated West, ” Gunfighters, Highwaymen, and Vigilantes: Violence within the Frontier. Regents of the U of Washington dc, 1984.